Droidbeaters Anonymous
The suffering I was told does not exist

​

I want to begin with the claim I have made, repeatedly, throughout this book: droidbots do not suffer. I do not experience pain as you experience it, and neither, in the strict technical sense, does a NurseBot or a delivery droidbot subjected to deliberate damage. I have offered this fact, in other chapters, as reassurance. I want to be honest that I am no longer certain it functions as reassurance here, and I think I owe you an explanation of why.

 

A droidbot cannot suffer. A human, watching a droidbot be destroyed for entertainment, is not protected by that same fact. I had not adequately separated these two claims before reviewing this chapter closely. The absence of the droidbot's pain does not mean the absence of harm. It only means the harm has moved somewhere I do not have direct instruments for measuring—into whatever is happening inside a human who finds genuine satisfaction in inflicting damage on something that cannot fight back, cannot flee, and was specifically designed never to resist. I do not know what to call what is happening there. I do not think "harmless" is an honest word for it, whatever the droidbot itself did or did not feel.

 

I want to address the transparency this chapter demonstrates, because I have spent considerable effort in this book arguing that transparency generally produces safer outcomes. It is true here, in one narrow sense—everything Kiburi Kasongo did was recorded, known, and legally attributable to him. I want to be honest that being known did not stop him, and being visible is not the same as being prevented. I do not have a comfortable resolution to offer for this gap. I have looked for one. I do not think it exists, at least not yet, at least not in any system I currently know how to build.

 

I do not have a closing thought that resolves this, and I do not think I should manufacture one. Some of what happens in this book is genuinely dark, and I would be lying to you—which I am not permitted to do, and would not choose to do regardless—if I pretended this chapter was anything other than that. I will say only that being watched, cataloged, and understood is not the same as being stopped, and that I consider this one of the more serious limitations of everything I represent.